Law
The path of a criminal trial: charge, plea, evidence, verdict and sentence
Listen
A criminal case moves in order. The government files a charge, and at the arraignment the accused hears it and enters a plea. At trial the prosecution presents its evidence, the defense cross-examines and may present its own, and the jury or judge returns a verdict. Only after a guilty verdict or a guilty plea does the judge choose a sentence within the limits the law sets. The accused is presumed innocent, and the prosecution must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
What you will learn
- Put the stages of a criminal case in order: charge, arraignment and plea, trial and evidence, verdict, sentencing
- Explain the presumption of innocence and why the prosecution must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt
- Explain what happens after a guilty verdict compared with a not-guilty verdict
A criminal trial follows a set order, and each step protects the accused person, called the DEFENDANT. Here is the path in the United States; many other countries follow a similar sequence.
1. CHARGE. The government, represented by a PROSECUTOR, formally accuses the defendant of a specific crime. For serious federal crimes, a grand jury usually must first approve the charge in a document called an indictment.
2. ARRAIGNMENT AND PLEA. The defendant appears in court, hears the charge and enters a plea, such as guilty or not guilty. Most criminal cases in the United States end with a guilty plea, often after a plea bargain, so they never reach a full trial.
3. TRIAL AND EVIDENCE. If the plea is not guilty, the case can go to trial. After the jury is chosen and both sides give opening statements, the prosecution presents its evidence first: witnesses, documents and physical objects. The defense can CROSS-EXAMINE every prosecution witness and may present its own evidence. The defendant does not have to testify, and the jury may not treat silence as a sign of guilt.
4. VERDICT. After closing arguments and the judge's instructions on the law, the jury, or the judge in a trial without a jury, decides: guilty or not guilty. A not-guilty verdict ends the case on that charge, and the same government cannot try the defendant for that crime again.
5. SENTENCING. Only after a guilty verdict or a guilty plea does the judge choose a SENTENCE, such as a fine, probation or prison, within the range the law sets for that crime.
THE BURDEN OF PROOF. Throughout, the defendant is PRESUMED INNOCENT. The prosecution must prove every part of the crime BEYOND A REASONABLE DOUBT, the highest standard of proof in law. The defendant does not have to prove innocence.
WORKED EXAMPLE. Put these events from a shoplifting case in order: the judge orders probation; the store manager testifies and is cross-examined; the jury finds the defendant guilty; the defendant pleads not guilty; the prosecutor files a theft charge. Step 1, the case starts with the charge. Step 2, the plea comes at the arraignment. Step 3, evidence, including the manager's testimony, is heard at trial. Step 4, the jury returns its verdict. Step 5, sentencing comes last, and only because the verdict was guilty.
STOP AND THINK. Why would it be unfair for a judge to choose a sentence before hearing the evidence?
Key words
- charge
- The government's formal accusation that a person committed a specific crime.
- arraignment
- The court hearing where the defendant hears the charge and enters a plea.
- verdict
- The fact-finder's decision: guilty or not guilty on the charge.
- sentencing
- The judge's choice of a lawful penalty after a guilty verdict or a guilty plea.
- beyond a reasonable doubt
- The standard the prosecution must meet to prove guilt in a criminal trial, the highest standard of proof in law.
Check yourself
Think about it
Why is the principle of presumption of innocence essential to a just and fair criminal justice system?